Snowflakes.
Jun. 17th, 2005 01:23 pmA couple of weeks ago, George W. Bush stood up at his bully pulpit with 21 babies from three weeks to almost two years arrayed about his feet as if he were some Jesus figure suffering the little children, and he used them to illustrate Snowflake Embryo Adoption, an organization whose mission is obvious in its name. His point was that discard embryos should not be used for stem cell research because there were other things that could have been done with them. His comment was "there's no such thing as a spare embryo."
Well, yes there is. ( One thing Snowflakes doesn't tell you is... )
This perversion of the word "adoption" is meant to make us consider the embryo as a person-- one can only adopt another person, while embryos are still legally property-- and to obtrude the concept of personhood into the embryonic stage, and thereby reach the stage where abortion is made to seem untenable. And when that happens, IVF too will be untenable. Bush can't attack it now, that would be political suicide. But that is, ultimately, the goal. A little moral incoherence, a little deceptiveness in one's ethical stance, is apparently a small price to pay for some good political capital.
Well, yes there is. ( One thing Snowflakes doesn't tell you is... )
This perversion of the word "adoption" is meant to make us consider the embryo as a person-- one can only adopt another person, while embryos are still legally property-- and to obtrude the concept of personhood into the embryonic stage, and thereby reach the stage where abortion is made to seem untenable. And when that happens, IVF too will be untenable. Bush can't attack it now, that would be political suicide. But that is, ultimately, the goal. A little moral incoherence, a little deceptiveness in one's ethical stance, is apparently a small price to pay for some good political capital.