Elf Sternberg

The reporting is uneven. There's not even a whiff of an attempt on the reporter's part to address the merits of the arguments for and against. The ID people are allowed to make their claims loudly and emphatically, although the reporter's own skepticism comes through loud and clear.

For shame, Elf. You should know better. This is MarketPlace. It's a show about the economy and the market, not about science. They were addressing the merits of the marketing of the movie...basically, marketing a niche movie with big-budget PR, and whether that was a good idea. Whether the arguments contained in the film had merit or not had nothing to do with the coverage they were doing, or normally do.

You shouldn't come down on them for doing their job.