Irving Kristol is Dead. Good Riddance.
Sep. 19th, 2009 08:45 amIrving Kristol, one of the major founders of the modern conservative movement, is dead. Like Bill Buckley, he wanted to found a movement with some intellectual credibility. As we now know, he has failed. The twin pillars of a religious moralism and unrestricted capitalism were inevitably doomed: the marketplace will move to satisfy our most trivial desires, a universal acid dissolving the existing morality in our baser nature.
Kristol's solution was to deny both democracy and universal truth. In order to preserve his idea of a great nation, the intellectual elites, the very people loathed and feared by the Teabaggers, must engage in a Noble Lie:
Kristol believed he was already among the "happy elites" capable of steering a docile public for their common good, "chosen by History." The neoconservative movement remains animated by this belief: that they are better than everyone else, and it is not education people need, but leadership and obedience. The Bush years were populated with calls to "deference the president," something that neither Clinton nor Obama ever got. That kind of poison, the notion that one side somehow deserves different treatment, will rot in the national veins for years to come, and yet the right has seized it through glib deceit and an illicitly seized penumbra of religious conviction.
So good riddance to Irving Kristol. I'd rather deal with Pat Buchanan's honest conservatism, however befouled it maybe with trite racism and anti-Semitism, than the dishonest flavor put forth by people committed to a tribal "winning at all costs," even of their own respectability.
Kristol's solution was to deny both democracy and universal truth. In order to preserve his idea of a great nation, the intellectual elites, the very people loathed and feared by the Teabaggers, must engage in a Noble Lie:
There are different kinds of truths for different kinds of people. There are truths appropriate for children; truths that are appropriate for students; truths that are appropriate for educated adults; and truths that are appropriate for highly educated adults, and the notion that there should be one set of truths available to everyone is a modern democratic fallacy. It doesn't work.Conservatives gleefully point out that whenever some liberal talks about overturning the existing political order (which is insanely conservative by all historical standards, thanks to people like Kristol and Buckley), those liberals never seem to understand that they're likely to end up among the ruled and not the rulers.
Kristol believed he was already among the "happy elites" capable of steering a docile public for their common good, "chosen by History." The neoconservative movement remains animated by this belief: that they are better than everyone else, and it is not education people need, but leadership and obedience. The Bush years were populated with calls to "deference the president," something that neither Clinton nor Obama ever got. That kind of poison, the notion that one side somehow deserves different treatment, will rot in the national veins for years to come, and yet the right has seized it through glib deceit and an illicitly seized penumbra of religious conviction.
So good riddance to Irving Kristol. I'd rather deal with Pat Buchanan's honest conservatism, however befouled it maybe with trite racism and anti-Semitism, than the dishonest flavor put forth by people committed to a tribal "winning at all costs," even of their own respectability.