NPR's article yesterday on
the risks of the HPV vaccine has to be one of the most irresponsible piece of
journamalism I've heard on NPR in a long while.
It starts off with this quote:
There's a new report on health problems associated with the vaccine against HPV - that's the human papillomavirus, which can lead to cervical cancer.
And then it goes on, paragraph after paragraph, sound bite after sound bite, to show how there is
no discernable pattern of risk evident in the data, and overwhelmingly,
the lives saved by the HPV vaccine far outweigh the risk of vaccination. Cervical cancer kills 4000 women every year, and the CDC says that two deaths from the vaccine are "suspect." Cutting deaths down by a factor of 2000 is a huge, huge benefit to the population.
These are the gold standards of vaccination deployment. They're the kind of results vaccine researchers look for: a lowering of risk factors by at least one order of magnitue (and in this case,
three orders of magnitude), and no discernable causal pattern of risks related to vaccination. Gardisil's risk profile is exactly the same as other childhood vaccinations-- a point Wilson never raised.
Brenda Wilson, the reporter, chose to end her piece with this comment:
To put things into perspective, Dr. Halsey reminds us that people of all ages have health problems and all people die, even young people the age of those who got the vaccine.
That's the sort of, "Well, kids die sometime. Yours might. It might be the vaccine's fault, but researchers are just gonna shrug their shoulders anyway."
The Christian Right hates Gardisil. They hate it with a passion because it's the first vaccine for a sexually transmitted disease. For them, sex ought to be risky. It ought to be frightening. Focus on the Family's "
position of the HPV vaccine" is that Gardisil will convince young women that sexual intercourse is socially acceptable and will encourage promiscuity, whereas if young women know they're at risk for cervical cancer they'll be more likely to abstain. It's all about controlling women with fear; technological alleviations of fearful sex are an abomination before their god.
Nothing in Wilson' piece supported the opening sentence. The presentation, the opening
fnord and the overweening de-emphasis on the nature of science, the lack of comparison of these results to those of the polio vaccine, the rubella vaccine, or the meningitis vaccine-- all vaccinations that save lives-- all lead up to an enraging piece of journamalism that feeds into the Christian Right's agenda.
And yes, I've complained to NPR about this crap.